California Golden Blogs: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:





Church of Football

There are the obvious relations between church and football. Many people gather to pray on a particular day of the week, sometimes making sacrafices to hygiene for the sake of luck. What I'd like to talk to you about today are the fundamental structures of these two institutions that make football the religious experience that we know it is. Both institutions are geared toward keeping and instilling faith into their respective worshippers and do that very successfully by appealing to innate social responses. So let's take a look at those social responses in the setting of football and the identity of the fans, then we can look at specific Cal traditions to see this in our own Memorial Stadium.

Both institutions take advantage of conditioned responses by the power of sacred locations and sacred music. First of all, Memorial Stadium is sacred--yes, sacred with drunks and overflowing toilets, but still sacred. The feel of the wood benches, the view of the field from your seats, the smell of sun, sweat and booze, and if you're lucky, the bouncy feel of momentum turf beneath your feet. You probably have very strong feelings about memorial stadium. Now, what makes it so holy? I think it's because the perceptual concept is not muddled up by the mundane; its only purpose is football. Every Saturday (or so) in the fall we all have a visceral reaction to the events on the field where the importance of it all is reflected in your heart-pounding, which releases adrenaline, cheering, which releases dopamine, and generally the whole experience being reinforced by 70,000 fans. You associate this importance and these emotions with this place.

You also associate your experience with the music that accompanies the scene. (Think of it like Christmas music, you only hear it once a year, and love it or hate it, I bet you have the same reaction to it every year.) Music has been used over centuries in almost every religious group to solidify relations to and importance of events. Just as in church, in Cal traditions you might even notice different styles of music to envoke solemnity or celebration; either Hail to Cal or Palms of Victory respectively. We also have holy persons and holy days. Everyone knows Tedford is god, but there does seem to be a hierarchy of holy football persona -- from AD to water boy. Complicated and unseen relationships of these saints can be honored and discussed by the masses. Deities exists such as Andy Smith, Pappy Waldorf, and Marshawn Lynch. Current players and assistant coaches may be working their way toward sainthood right now. As for the holy days, we all know Big Game is the holiest day of the year with its own special chants and traditions. Minor feast days might include Homecoming, the first game of the year, or the first day season tickets go on sale. The game traditions that we see every game day act to solidify our faith as well as our group identity as Cal fans.

The most important part of the group identity is, well, the identity; the rules and beliefs that define the members of the group. These are the kind of rules that state "thou shall not harass opposing fans while they are in line for the toilet" and "thou shall not wear red during Big Game week". Often this is most easily shown (and defined) by an 'us versus them' frame. Many groups are only defined after tossing out the undesirable actions and then seeing what the group finds desirable. When you travel to U$C, and you see 8-year-olds cursing at you, I hope this helps to show what is 'undesirable' in a fan and that part of the Cal fan group identity is a sense of class and restraint. Our differing group identities may explain why the University of Oklahoma Alumni Association makes about two to three times more money on apparel then Cal. It's because to be a "Sooner" you wear Sooner clothing, apparently constantly. Here at Cal, we don't believe that you are only a Bear fan. You can be a Bear fan on Saturday, a 'Niners fan on Sunday, and an A's fan on Monday. What's great about these rules are that they are self-policing within the group; make a mistake and you are corrected by your fellow fans (see chant "Take Off that Red Shirt"), do well and you are given peer support.

Besides personal experience, groups are also defined and connected by the history or narrative of the group. Cal certainly has a rich and telling narrative that, until now, has been only told in pieces and on an individual basis. Those with 'book-learnin' call this mnemonic tradition which includes what we remember as well as how we remember it. This means we remember sensory experiences (feel of the seats) as well as remember it through the interpretation of the group (U$C always cheats therefore...). The interpretation of information is very important -- it gives us a way to place emphasis and importance of some actions over others. The Cal narrative would explain why most Cal fans feel pretty confident that Pappy Waldorf is a more legendary coach than Jack Clark. Also, my husband Ragnarok reminds me that the name Pappy sounds very cuddly while Jack Clark gives kids people nightmares. In case you were wondering, it's because of this sociobiographical memory that accounts for the pride, pain, and shame we feel in reaction to the group history -- even to events before we were born. Basically, all of these different areas give us a concept of a Cal fan -- and lord help you if you do something that clashes with that concept.

Now, what you may not consider with all these game day factors, is that the University is very aware of them. Each department's marketing works very hard to take the handful of recognizable Cal artifacts (Campanile, Oski, Walking Bear) and turn them into a unique, but familiar, identifier for each different campus entity (Haas, Boalt, Optometry School, etc...). So when the Director of Gameday Experience (Megan Mosness) decides that we need more piped in music, it's with consideration of what Cal fans expect versus what money it will bring in. Now, I think what makes the piped in music especially obnoxious is that it clashes with our concept of being a Cal fan -- we love our band and we don't sell out. Traditions that stick are aligned with our concept of Cal. This may be one reason that we stopped using live bears as mascots; our concept of Oski was more classy and less vicious (besides the obvious maiming lawsuits). Along those same lines, some traditions match far too well to get accepted into tradition. In 2004, the Cal Band held a contest for a new Cal song. They picked California Triumph, a great song that felt to them "like a Cal song". It did, but it hasn't been accepted by the fans. Not because it clashes with the concept but because we already have songs that fit that meme (any unit of cultural information, such as a practice or idea). In a language, a new word will not replace an old word unless that old word changes meaning leaving a meme gap. For example, I hate the "Roll on You Bears" chant. It's dull and depressing. But it stays because it fills a specific need in the culture.

I hope that this is interesting. We live in a tiny Cal fan universe governed by social rules imposed by our history and enforced by our friends. In closing I'd like to add to go with this church of football, we also have our own words of prayer. Go Bears.

The opinions expressed in a FanPost are not necessarily those of the California Golden Blogs or any of its authors. However, they are just as important as the opinions of any of the authors. And doubly so as compared to TwistNHook!

2 recs | Comment 16 comments

Story-email Email | Print |

Comments

Display:

Full Disclosure

Yes, AndBears is my wife, and the author of this previous post. I asked her to write this for our old site (she was a Cog Sci major at Cal), but now, with the FanPosts feature, she can get all the front-page credit.

Personally, I think this is a fascinating study in just how much football and organized religion have in common (and what that might imply about our collective relationship to college football). I hope you agree.

So, basically, you gotta Go Bears!

by ragnarok on May 17, 2008 11:58 AM PDT   0 recs

See, dear readers

All you have to do to get your FanPosts featured on the front page is marry one of our eligible writers.

HydroTech is single, ladies! And naively political!

www.CaliforniaGoldenBlogs.com

by TwistNHook on May 17, 2008 11:02 PM PDT to parent up   0 recs

Speaking of deities

Marshawn Lynch, the patron saint of Applebee’s and Skee-Ball.

by tastyb33f on May 17, 2008 1:37 PM PDT   0 recs

then again,

in so many games last season I’ve actually prayed for an act of god… some last minute intervention… something, anything… PLS GOD HELP!!! but the help never came. oh wait, I guess it is like church.

interesting read.

by danzig on May 17, 2008 6:50 PM PDT   0 recs

Oral tradition

My wife’s uncle is a Cal alum from the early 60s, and I’ve met a few more in his age range, and their immediate reaction to hearing “USC” is to say “the best team money can buy!” – without fail – mnemonic tradition in action. I understand that Cal and Stanford first attempted to evict USC from the Pacific Coast Conference in 1924 on the grounds that there was funny business going on with recruiting and, ah, informal compensation – an early start to sociobiographical memory, in other words.

This is a convincing case from a cognitive standpoint, and I think there are probably a good number more comparisons that you could make. For instance, the inverse relationship between the superficial differences between a religion, and the ferocity of the conflict between its adherents could be applied across several oppositions in the Pac-10. For another, you have your casual adherents as well – for USC, the equivalent of Christmas and Easter Christians (Rosh Hashanah and Pesach Jews?) would be the fans who only turn out for ucla and Notre Dame games.

by DC Trojan on May 17, 2008 6:54 PM PDT   0 recs

Tshirt idea

DC Trojan’s comment made me realize what CGB needs: a store, like mgostore (that’s two links to mgoblog things from me today – what can I say, Brian runs a good college sports blog).

First idea: gold tshirt, silhouettes of reggie and OJM’s faces with “USC” between them, and below: “The best team money can buy.”

You can have that one for free.

The Bear will not quit, the Bear will not die

by Calfan on May 18, 2008 7:09 AM PDT to parent up   0 recs

All I can say to that...

... is that if the 07 – 08 basketball team was the best that money can buy, it calls into question just how feeble a pittance Mayo was getting.

by DC Trojan on May 18, 2008 9:48 PM PDT to parent up   0 recs

Twistnhook needs to post a sort of response

to this post. It’s title should be “Football is the opiate of the masses.”

by oaktownmario on May 18, 2008 12:52 AM PDT   0 recs

Take a deep breath

It should be noted that during any game spent in the student section, one smells the a different “opiate of the masses” at least a couple times. :)

The Bear will not quit, the Bear will not die

by Calfan on May 18, 2008 6:41 AM PDT to parent up   0 recs

All I know

is that the history of all hitherto existing society is the history of class struggles.

USC and Stanford, UCLA and Cal, Oregon and Wazzu, in a word, oppressor and oppressed, stood in constant opposition to one another, carried on an uninterrupted, now hidden, now open fight, a fight that each time ended, either in a revolutionary reconstitution of society at large, or in the common ruin of the contending classes.

And then Jeff Tedford arrived on the scene. Oppressor, here we come! GO BEARS!

www.CaliforniaGoldenBlogs.com

by TwistNHook on May 18, 2008 8:03 AM PDT to parent up   0 recs

October in the Pac-10?

The vanguard of the elite, preparing the overthrow of a dissolute ancien regime? Perhaps so, though there is the distraction of the paper tigers of Westwood, or should that be paper baby bruins?

by DC Trojan on May 18, 2008 10:09 PM PDT to parent up   0 recs

All this talk of communism has me thinking of President Reagan's world-changing speech

We could really use that type of strong speech now over by Memorial Stadium!

“Sandy Barbour, tear down those trees!”

www.CaliforniaGoldenBlogs.com

by TwistNHook on May 18, 2008 10:46 PM PDT to parent up   0 recs

So much to say...

To the concept of football and religion, generally: it’s always been a powerful and convincing metaphor to me. AndBears’ account is convincing – the analysis of iconography, holy days, hierarchy, sociobiographic memory, and good/evil narratives all ring true. For me though, the central truth of the metaphor – eclipsing all other aspects – has always been faith. Football, like belief in an explicitly religious higher power (Tedford’s ironic inclusion notwithstanding), requires a leap of faith that defies logical explanation. Any of us who have ever tried to convey the importance of Cal football – of this game, that very moniker belying its all-consuming power – to a non-fan (a non-believer? a doubter, a pagan?) know just how difficult it is to explain why we care so much. The experience is profoundly personal. A game ticket by itself, like a bible on a library shelf, is empty of meaning. They are gateways to belief, but not belief themselves. Faith itself cannot be so easily transferred or created.

I’ve tried to write about this before, but I’ve never been happy with the result. Whatever prose I end up with at the end feels hollow, devoid of meaning. Inevitably, it’s either too zealous or too sociological, but never satisfactorily capturing that nearly unique quality of being a Cal fan: we are zealots, but we’re well educated enough to know it. When the pomp and ceremony of it all becomes too much, we punctuate it with wit and irony, assuring ourselves that we know it’s just a game. I think it explains why the Sooners sell more than us. But if in conversation we swing the pendulum too far and someone actually says “it’s just a game,” we chastise them for their crisis of faith. It’s not just a game, it’s our game.

I once tried to write a Golden Bears version of Footprints in the Sand. Instead of being spoken by the Lord, the last line – “it was then that I carried you” – was spoken by Oski. Even now I’m not sure if I would call it psalm or parody, scripture or satire.

I could go on, but I think it’s appropriate, as I write this on a Sunday morning, that I lay this response to rest. I’ll finish by making a final comparison, or rather linking to one: mgoblog’s eulogy to Bo Schembechler. Though it’s not about Cal, it may be the finest short-form sports writing I’ve ever read (plus, they wear maize and blue and gold and have rivals in red, so it’s ok). Ostensibly about sports and war, the religious tone is ever-present. Worth a click if you’ve never read it before. Read it with the music.

The Bear will not quit, the Bear will not die

by Calfan on May 18, 2008 6:39 AM PDT   0 recs

Cal Football History Project

(4 comments on the same post without even waiting for a reply – I know, I’m crazy. But I had one last thing to say…)

Is it weird to anyone else that the Cal Football History Project (the “until now” link in AndBears’ post) is requiring donations just to help with the project? When I saw that page had a “Help Tell the Story” section, I thought it would be a solicitation for Old Blues to share information that might not be recorded anywhere else – a way to reach out to primary sources. Or maybe a wiki for fans to contribute to.

I know the Athletic Department wants our money, and lord knows I give it to them, but I thought that was a little over the top. You’d think we would be able to “Share memories about the Bears with Ron” and “Cast [our] vote for All Time Cal Football Team” without ponying up $7000…

The Bear will not quit, the Bear will not die

by Calfan on May 18, 2008 7:19 AM PDT   0 recs

And there's missonary-esque behavior too

There almost seems to be a universal effort to educate those who don’t understand our fascination and obsession with the game, as if we are trying to convert the heathens to our church of football. I know I’m not immune to this, pretty much anyone who lives near me starts to wonder about my football/basketball obsessions and is forced to learn the game. Its resulted in a whole lot more people living and dying by every yard. I can only hope that if the especially lean years ever return, these people stay members of the church =)

by 408 on May 18, 2008 5:33 PM PDT   0 recs

Neat

You know, it was nice seeing the juxtaposition of religion and football. I mean, I think we all sort of intuitively knew about it, but it was nice seeing it in words. Especially cause I can’t talk too good.

But a couple of things I need to quibble with (yes, I know):

1. Leaving out Joe Kapp from the roll of Cal’s canonized? How on earth? The last QB to take Cal to the Rose Bowl; the guy who once said (after scrambling and taking on a linebacker) “running out of bounds is for white boys”; and the architect (okay, the Captain Peachfuzz) of The Play. Seriously, Joe deserves some major props.
2. Failing to include the appearance of miracles as a way to help reinforce the faith. Burning Bush or The Play—which is the true miracle? Yeah, I thought so.

Other than that, nice post.

Go Bears!

by SoCal Oski on May 19, 2008 12:28 PM PDT   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to the 3rd Best Sports-Oriented Cal Blog on the net, where work on the giant golden statue of Nate Longshore continues day and night

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

Forsett_small
Nate Longshore: Setting the Record Straight
Bear_small
FanPosts vs. FanShots : The Dialectic Struggle
Tedford_south_park_sml_small
NCAA Football 2009 - Cal-related thoughts
Erin_oski_armedforces_small
Women's Huddle!

Recent FanPosts

P1_marshawn_small
DBD 7.24.08 You must think me painfully self-absorbed
P1_marshawn_small
DBD 7.23.08 Who else is hung over right now?
P1_marshawn_small
DBD 7.22.08 I welcome the eternal slumber
P1_marshawn_small
DBD 7.21.08 WE'RE RICH! WE'RE RICH! Plus The Woz speaks!
Thirsty2_small
Scout Boards
P1_marshawn_small
DBD 7.18.08 Baby's First Bear Dump
P1_marshawn_small
DBD 7/17/08 Please Televise the Revolution
P1_marshawn_small
DBD 7.16.08 Berkeley, Going To Take Over The World!

Post_icon New FanPost All FanPosts Carrot-mini


Marshawnthusiasts!

Bear_small ragnarok

Script_cal_small HydroTech

Cal_football_2005_09_16_roll_07_012_small CBKWit

P1_marshawn_small TwistNHook

P4572527reg_small yellow fever

ad

Site Meter